McDermott's Guide to Drug Treatment
1993
Lifeline Project
This guide was first published by Lifeline Project, Manchester, UK. This electronic version may be freely distributed electronically or as hard copy. However, be warned that you are missing out on Mike Linnell's brilliant illustrations. Introduction/why do you want to get help? There are hundreds of different reasons why people decide they need help with a drug problem. Here are some of the most common ones: Your parents have sussed you out, so you want to get them off your back. Your boss has sussed you out, and you've got to pay for your drugs somehow. Your partner says that they'll leave if you don't -- and it looks like they mean it this time. You've been nicked again. Unless you can give the court something reasonable in your plea of mitigation, you're going to jail. Do not pass go. Do not collect a methadone detox on the way. The £200 isn't going to be any use where you're going. You finally recognize that you don't have any control over your drug use. You want to stop for a while, or at least try to cut down, but you don't seem to have any control. Your willpower keeps on slipping, just long enough to break your determination. Given that you feel incapable of helping yourself, perhaps somebody else can help you. So, you've just robbed the last twenty out of your dad's wallet/wife's purse/sister's piggy bank, you've shot, smoked or snorted all the gear, you need to do something before they find out and finally cut you off. They've been on at you for long enough to see somebody about the problem, but who do you see? There's so many different places, all offering different types of thing. Do you need methadone? A detox? What about the black box? Accupuncture? Does it work? Before you sign your life away, you need to read McDermott's Guide to Drug Treatment -- the first no-bullshit Michelin guide for smackheads, crackheads, temazzie monsters and others in need of a temporary escape clause. A caution Before you decide to go to a drugs agency, there are a few things that you should know about drug treatment in the UK. If you go to see a doctor, a social worker or a probation officer, the person that you see will have received some training for the job. If you go to a drugs agency, there worker that you see is unlikely to have been trained as a drugs worker. They may have trained in another discipline but the amount that they actually know about drugs or drug problems varies immensely. This lack of knowledge will often permeate the whole of the agency. If the boss has very little drug-specific knowledge it is unlikely that he or she will insist on it in his staff. As a consequence, Britain has drug services that are typified by their lack of professionalism. The unstated position that is implicit here is, 'they're only drug addicts, anybody can deal with their problems', when in fact, too many drugs workers are unable to identify the issues even when they are spelled out for them. The expansion of drugs agencies over the last ten years or so has been fueled by political pressures and the availability of money, rather than any proven success at addressing a particular problem. Much of what drug services do is about justifying their existance or building empires and securing salaries, rather than addressing problems effectively. That said, there are many good, committed workers out there who will do their best to help you, and even the ones who aren't can be useful if you learn how to work the system and play the game. The key thing to remember though, when it comes to drugs services, is the principle 'let the customer beware'. Who are you doing it for? When you begin to think about getting some kind of help for a drug problem, you need to think about what it is exactly that you want to do and why. When people are asked why they first enter drug treatment of any kind, the first bunch of reasons in the list above are much more common than the last. A drug problem is something that depends largely on definition. For many people, their only problem is how to get enough drugs, or enough money to pay for them. Fair enough. this booklet is not trying to force anyone to stop using drugs. Drugs are cool, exciting, and they make you feel good. We know that this is true, or else why would you be in such a mess. The goal of most forms of treatment is to try and convince you otherwise. I'm sure that you've all come across them before -- well-meaning, social work types with their L registration cars and their £90,000 houses in the bohemian part of town. Took a couple of whiffs on a joint once when they were a student and now they talk about 'my hell on drugs'. The first thing to say is that if you are looking for a miracle cure, look elsewhere. Only God works miracles. The only totally effective treatment programme I know of was in China. First time they caught you, you got twenty years in the re-education camp. The second time, they used the magic bullet. The one to the back of the head. And even that was only effective because you knew that they would catch you. If people thought they could get away with it, they'd use, death penalty or no death penalty. As with drugs, different things work for different people. If you are seeking treatment because you genuinely are motivated to try to stop using, then you stand a very strong chance of succeeding regardless of what type of treatment you choose. However, you can probably increase your chances even further if you pick a type of help that suits to your personality and your circumstances. Why do people use drugs? People use drugs for an wide range of reasons. Some people use intoxicating drugs for religious reasons, like the communion wine in this culture, smoking ganga in Rastafarianism or drinking the sacred brown- mixed among that curious North-Western tribe, the Tetleybittermen. Others use drugs to medicate illness, like some of the the community care cases that we all know and love. Fact of the matter is, a great deal of drug use, legal and illegal, does not produce any problems. However, some people and some drugs just don't mix. For every one person who can use the brown on high days and holidays, there's another ten who are sitting clucking in a cold flat because they are too sick to get out on the street and sell their arse. For every one person who likes a line of charlie before they go out trying to pick up a lover, there's another who just sold their house because they couldn't keep from spending the mortgage money on rock. Treatment usually seeks to do one of two things. It either attempts to stabilize one's drug use, to reduce the harm associated with it, or it seeks to help you achieve abstinence from drugs. Which, if either, of those two aims is yours is something that only you can know. However, it does help if you are clear about what you want. Too often, people go along to drugs agencies and think, Òwhat is the best thing to tell them in order to get what I want?' Perhaps we should just tell them what we want, because you'll only get whatever it is they are going to give you, regardless of what you say. Some theories of drug addiction argue that drug users will never stop until they reach rock-bottom. Different people reach rock-bottom at different times. Some never do. Drug addiction is a relatively new phenomena in Britain, but as far as we can see, some people may continue using all their adult lives. The negative consequences of drug use are a product of the relationship between drug, the mind-set of the individual using them, and the social situation in which the drugs are taken. Thus, somebody who injects large amounts of diamorphine on a daily basis to relieve the pain of cancer is not regarded as having a drug problem, whereas somebody who smokes a large amount of brown to relieve the pain of living is seen as having a very serious problem indeed. Academics have rightly pointed out that a great deal of the harm that is seen as being caused by drug use is in fact a product of the way that society reacts to the issue. So one of the most common problems is the illegal status of drugs, which causes people to experience problems with the police and the courts. This also drives the prices of drugs artificially high, and so some people end up committing crime to pay for their habit. These harms may or may not be the fault of society, nevertheless, they are still harms. If you are experiencing problems as a result of your drug use, it is easier to change your own patterns of drug use than it is to change society. What is the nature of your problem? Your first step on the route to resolving your problem, is to try to identify just what the problem is. Other people may feel that they know what the problem is -- you take illegal drugs. This, in itself, rarely constitutes a problem for anybody. On the other hand, you might be experiencing so many problems that you can't sort out which ones are related to the drugs that you are using, from those that are simply a part of your day to day life. Some people will be quite capable of identifying their problems for themselves, whereas others may need some help with this. For such people, a drug advice and information centre will be the first port of call. These services used to describe themselves as 'counselling' services and were avoided like the plague. Staff tended to be either well-meaning do-gooders who didn't have a clue, or they were just corrupt know- nothings who were earning Brewsters' for sitting on their arses. This last group were infinitely preferable to the first lot. If you weren't careful, they'd be trying to persuade you to do a 'family sculpt' or tell your feelings to a chair. Fortunately, these are now an endangered species, although they can still be found in certain parts of the country. Anyway, a good advice and information project can sit you down and try to help you identify what your problems are, and give you advice on what the various options are. Bad ones will identify problems that you never recognized as problems and tell you that only they can help you get over them. This booklet intends to play a similar role, but it cannot give specific information about services available in your area, so ask your friends, see if any of them can recommend a good drugs agency or worker. Harm reduction Many services claim that they now operate according to a 'harm reduction' philosophy. This rather grand term means that some drugs workers have finally started listening to drug users rather than pretending that they know it all. Before we go any further, I must point out there are some experts who feel that the very idea of frug treatment is a nonsense. They believe addiction is not a 'curable disease', but a particular set of goals and values. Some people like to take legal drugs like alcohol and tobacco, other like to take illegal drugs like cocaine and heroin. Some people like to spend £1000 a week skiing, others like to spend £1000 a week on crack. Because of the difficulty in actually defining what the problem is, there are similar difficulties coming up with forms of treatment that are effective with even a majority of people who enroll in any particular programme. There is an old saying in the drugs and alcohol treatment field that goes, ÒIt doesn't matter what you do, a third get better, a third get worse, and a third stay the same.Ó For this reason, a wide range of treatment options are available, some very different to others. Hopefully, this booklet will help you choose the one that best suits you. What services are available, and where do I get them from? Advice/Information The drug advice and information service should probably be your first port of call. Unfortunately, most areas dont have a stand-alone advice and information unit -- they tend to be part of a bigger project, such as a Drug Dependency Clinic or a counselling service. Where this is the case, those agencies might not be quite so committed to the quality of the advice and information that they give out. Test them, ask the workers questions that you know the answers to in order to see whether they know the answers as well. That should give you some insight into the quality of the advice or information that you get from them. These agencies do what they say they do -- offer advice and information. If you've got a problem, they'll have suggestions as to what you should do about it. They should also be able to refer you on to a more appropriate service if necessary. Unfortunately, because many advice and information services are also counselling agencies, and because the people who fund counselling services want to see results (i.e., numbers), many agencies will immediately suggest that what you need is a spot of counselling (see below) and can you come back next week. Therefore, you should be clear about what it is that you want. If you want to have a chat about your drug use with some sad old dear once a week, then that's fine by me. If you want to secure a supply of methadone , or you want to come off, then there may well be other, more appropriate services. Counselling In the early eighties, counselling agencies dominated drug service provision in the U.K. There are a number of historical reasons for this. Before the eighties, there were only a few drug dependency units in the U.K., mostly dealing with old heroin addicts from the sixties. When the new wave of brown heroin flooded the country around about 1980, parents began screaming 'what are you going to do for little Johnny'. By this time, maintenance prescribing had fallen out of fashion, so many local authorities funded voluntary sector drugs agencies. Of course, they were set up by people who had little idea what to do about the issue. So they looked around. Drug Dependency Clinics are run by ...psychiatrists. What do psychiatrists do? They cure people by talking to them. (In fact, they really cure people by giving them drugs or ECT, but how were they to know that?) Anyway, psychiatrists are expensive, so perhaps we should hire counsellors? So what is counselling? Well, there are almost as many different types of psychotherapeutic counselling as there are counsellors. In classical Freudian psychotherapy, you would see a highly-trained therapist as often as three times a week, every week for a year. At the other extreme, you are more likely to see somebody who has been on an eight-hour, introduction- to-counselling course. Furthermore, the quality of counsellors is also very patchy. The basic idea is that by talking about your problems with a non- judgemental counsellor, you can be helped to see the obstacles thus bringing about change. What the funders weren't aware of, is the fact that at the heart of most models of counselling, is the idea that the victim (oops, sorry) that the client sets the agenda and decides what changes they feel they want to make. The problem being, that at any given time, a majority of drug users actually don't want to stop taking drugs, and those that do rarely find that counselling offers them any concrete help with that process. As a consequence, drugs counsellors have tended to focus on the other areas of the client's lives. If you do have a particular problem, for example, past sexual abuse or some emotional difficulty, then you may find counselling helpful. However, it is not a 'cure' for addiction, nor is it a magic wand that can change the way that you think and feel overnight, and a more specialized counsellor, like a sexual abuse therapist or a marrage guidance counsellor might be better trained and more experienced. So before you enter into a counselling contract, get the counsellor to justify what they think they can offer you, and why. Remember, they are providing a service, and if you don't think that what they offer is appropriate, then you need to tell them that. Out-patient detox. If you want to stop using opiate drugs like heroin and you find that you are unable to stop, one option is to go for an out-patient methadone detox. At one time, it was difficult to find a doctor who was prepared to prescribe methadone. However, in recent years there has been an enormous expansion in the use of methadone. A few words about the pro's and con's of methadone might be in order here. Methadone is a synthetic opiate. This means that it was chemically synthesized, rather than comes from the opium poppy, and has very similar effects to natural opiates. Doctors like to use it in preference to heroin for a number of reasons. This means it stays in the body for a long time, unlike heroin, which only lasts a few hours. It can be prescribed in an oral mixture, which is intended to break the injection habit, and if it is prescribed in high doses, it becomes difficult getting enough heroin to have any impact. On the other hand, it is regarded by many as producing an inferior buzz and being more addictive than heroin. Withdrawals are felt to last longer with a methadone habit than a heroin habit. Also, it does seem that those people who go onto a methadone script are likely to stay addicted for longer than those who don't, although they may also suffer fewer problems than those who avoid methadone. If you want to try a detox, remember that methadone isn't the only option. Some doctors may be prepared to use di-hydro-codeine (DHC, DF118) or benzodiazapines or both. You need to decide which one you think is best for you. Where to get an out-patient detox? The obvious first port of call is your family doctor. In the past, many G.P.'s would throw you off their list if they knew that you had a drug problem. Today, many of them are more sympathetic. If he's not prepared to take on the task himself, ask him to refer you to your local Community Drug Team (CDT) or Drug Dependency Clinic (DDC). Many drug clinics will not take you onto their list unless you have first been referred by a G.P. Another alternative is to go to your advice and information service. If there is a waiting list at the DDC/CDT, they might well be able to fix you up with a G.P. who will take you on to his or her list for a detox. Finally, if they aren't any use, try approaching your Family Health Service Authority and telling them about your needs. They should be able to put you in touch with a doctor who is prepared to treat you. Methadone maintenance If you are experiencing problems as a result of opiate addiction and you either don't want to come off, or you can't manage to do it, you might want to think about methadone maintenance. This means that you will receive a maintenance dose of methadone for an extended period, until you feel ready to try to stop. At first, this sounds like a good deal. Free, legal drugs for as long as you want. However, there are drawbacks. Any addiction involves some surrender of personal freedom. On methadone maintenance, you have to be at the chemist, every day to pick up your script. You need to attend the clinic regularly. Your life is no longer your own -- key decisions about what you can or can't do will be made for you by a doctor or nurse. Sometimes, you may have to have to suffer the indignity of giving a urine sample to check whether you are using the drugs that they give you, and to check that you are not using on top. Again, I should stress that enrolling in methadone maintenance is likely to extend the period for which you are addicted. On the other hand, compared with having to find large sums of money every day, then finding a dealer who won't rip you off, only to find that the gear is lousy and hasn't sorted you anyway, methadone maintenance might be a good deal. Once again, it's a matter of personal choice, dependent on your particular circumstances. Where to get methadone maintenance If you do want methadone maintenance, it is most likely to be available at your local Drug Dependency Clinic or Community Drug Team. Some G.P.'s may prescribe methadone on a maintenance basis, but they are rare and they usually prefer it if you've already been assessed by a specialist drug service first. On the other hand, many DDC's or CDT's will only take people who have been referred by their G.P. Your local drugs advice/information service should be able to give you the details of your local services. A brief word about heroin maintenance In the golden era, before 1967, all doctors were allowed to prescribe heroin and cocaine for the treatment of addiction. However, this facility is now strictly limited to doctors in possession of a special license from the Home Office, most of whom are Consultant Psychiatrists who work at Drug Dependency Clinics. Although there has been a great deal of debate lately about the desirability of such prescribing, the actual number of doctors who are prepared to do it is very small, and those who will prescribe heroin or cocaine tend to only do it for a limited number of people. Why? Well, the reasoning seems to be that you can attract more people than you can treat by prescribing methadone, why bother? So all that I'll say about heroin maintenance is that it is theoretically possible, but it isn't very likely. In-patient detox If you find that you can't manage to stop taking drugs because the temptations around you to continue using are too great, you might benefit from an in-patient detoxification. These usually take place in a special hospital ward called a Drug Dependency Unit, although you could also end up on a general psychiatric ward. Some of the residential drug rehabilitation units (rehabs) are also now beginning to do in-patient detox, although this may be conditional on your agreeing to sign up for the full programme when your detox is complete. In-patient detox usually involves a relatively rapid reduction that may or may not be supplemented with sleeping medication once the methadone has stopped. A recent development has been the rapid naltrexone detox. This involves being put to sleep with large doses of sedatives, then being given opiate antagonists to flush the opiates out of the system. Although the worst of the turkey is done while you are asleep, your sleep patterns will still be disrupted for up to a month afterwards. Furthermore, this type of detox is physically traumatic, so requires a great deal of nursing attention to monitor the sleeping patient. In drug withdrawal, as in life, there are no short-cuts. Besides the medication, some hospitals also provide some kind of psychological therapy which may or may not be compulsorary. As with counselling, the nature and the quality of the therapy of offer is very variable. Some hospitals have well thought out programmes based on relapse prevention models, while others just have free-form encounter- type groups. There are a number of advantages in going into hospital to do a detox. You are removed from your immediate environment, which can give you a break from the everyday pressures of your life, and remove some of the temptation to go out and score. However, detox units are no different from anywhere else and you can often still score on the hospital ward. You are also going to have to face those pressures once you get out, so the situation is an artificial one, but the achievement involved in actually getting drug- free may well help you sustain your resolve. The type of therapy that is on offer at these places seems to have little clear discernable impact upon outcome rates. All detox programmes have a high drop-out rate and a high relapse rate, so you should not go in expecting a magical cure. The best predictor of success in drug treatment is the motivation of the patient. If you are really determined, you can get clean. If you find that you continue to relapse, then rather than doing detox after detox, you might find that you need the longer and more intensive regime of a residential rehabilitation programme. You can get information on in-patient detoxification facilities from your G.P., your C.D.T. or D.D.C., or from your local drug information and advice project. Residential rehabilitation Residential rehabilitation is the big daddy of drug treatment options. They usually involve a long stay, usually anywhere from six months to two years (though programmes are getting shorter). There are several different types of residential rehab (also known as a therapeutic community). They include: Concept Houses -- concept houses have a particular theory of addiction and recovery, sometimes specific to that organization, sometimes just based upon the Minnesota Method and the twelve step programmes. Religion-based therapeutic communities - it is rarely a condition of acceptance that one accepts the religious principles that inform the house, although there is usually some attempt to proselytize for a religious point of view. Non-ideological residential rehabilitation units - These are lacking a single, organizing dogma like the first two types and tend to use an eclectic mix of counselling, groupwork, relapse prevention, etc. Rehabilitation or brainwashing? The difference between the two is simply a matter of personal values. The aim of the residential rehabilitation unit is to totally restructure the personality, changing you from a person who thinks that drugs are a reasonable way of dealing with your problems, into a person who thinks that drugs are damaging your life, perhaps even killing you. Residential rehabs polarize the views of ex-residents. Some people believe that it was their stay in a rehab that saved their life. They are usually the final option when all other methods of help have failed, and are presented to the drug user as just that -- their last chance. Other people though, feel that the rehab that they stayed at actually damaged them. There has been little independent control or regulation of rehabs, and in the past, they tended to make extensive use of programme graduates, who would perpetuate abusive situations in the name of 'therapy'. Some examples: In one rehab, a female resident is told that she will not recover from her addiction unless she participates actively in the group therap[y sessions. She is encouraged to talk to the group about her experience of being sexually abused by her father. However, not all of the residents are committed to the therapeutic process. Some of the men regard this as as a sexual fantasy. Back on the streets a few weeks later, they gossip about her experiences. In another rehab, residents are woken up in the middle of the night. All the clocks are removed, all windows are shuttered. Staff begin a marathon session of sensory deprivation lasting several days that is intended to assist residents to regress to the point at which they were born. One resident suffers a total psychotic breakdown and is transferred to a psychiatric hospital. The major problem with residential rehabs, is that they are often staffed by people with very little training, but who believe that they have the magical power of cure. Because there is no single model of how best to deal with a drug problem, what you get is any number of competing theories. As a result, the idea has been spawned that anybody can be a drugs worker. No specific training is required, all you need is for somebody to give you a job -- you'll pick it up as you go along. In this context, the ex-user is a good idea. At least they understand the scene, and they know what worked for them. More numerous though, is the type that has trained to be a counsellor in order to better understand their own pathologies. Then they decide that they want to put their new found skills to the test -- and drugs has recently been one of the few growth areas for a trained counsellor. Unfortunately, some of these workers are just as dysfunctional as any drug user -- but they are less likely to get into legal difficulties as a consequence. You can learn a great deal during your stay at a rehab. You can learn about yourself and why you do the things that you do. You can learn work discipline, and get experience of what it is like to take on managerial responsibility. You can learn that it is possible to live without drugs for an extended period. Like in-patient detox, it is something of an artificial situation, but most rehabs make some efforts to slowly re-integrate residents back into the outside world. However, they tend to be rigidly heirarchical, and necessarily go in for somewhat strict discipline which can sometimes verge on the abusive -- for example, you might be forced to wear a jesters outfit for a week if you continuously crack jokes, or you might have to walk around with a big placard round your neck, telling the world that you are a liar and a thief or subit to some other equally demeaning practice. The point of all this, is to break down the old 'addict' personality and replace it with a new 'healthy' or 'non-deviant' personality. Like all forms of treatment, far more people relapse and return to use, but for those who are committed to attempting to stop using drugs, it is a strategy that works for some. Self-help groups. A self-help group is any group of people who come together for the purposes of supporting each other through a problem. Perhaps the largest and best-known of these groups is Alcoholics Anonymous, but there is laso Narcotics Anonymous (which focuses of drugs, both prescribed and illegal) and more specialized ones like Overeaters Anonymous and Sex Addicts Anonymous. Most of these groups are 'twelve-step programme', which means that they are based upon the twelve step model of Alcoholics Anonymous. Adherents of these groups claim that Twelve-step programmes are really a spiritual rather than religious programmes. The steps combine a set of tried and tested methods for staying drug or alcohol free, with a quasi- religious authority that exhorts members to change the things that they are able to change, and rely on a higher power to take care of the things that you can't change for yourself. Many people baulk at the overt religious nature of N.A., but it does have advantages over other drug treatment programmes. Support comes, not from paid workers, but from other people who have shared the same situation, and therefore often have a level of insight into the type of behaviour that addicts go in for. This results in a much greater level of commitment, and NA groups often provide a circle of support during that difficult period after stopping use. NA's strength is that it can pass on the stored experience of hundreds of thousands of addicts (which is how they prefer to be described) about the things that work for them in their struggle to stay drug free. Although the 12 step movement is not anything like as big in the U.K. as it is in America, there are still groups in most areas. You can find out about your local group by ringing World Service Organization at ?, or ask at your local advice and information or other drug service. So finally.... As you can see from this booklet, drug treatment is an enormously varied field with incredibly diverse standards. Some things you might find helpful, others you won't. The key to success is to shop around, find out what suits you. You should also remember, the majority of people stop using drugs on their own, without any help. Ultimately, the real work has to be done by you. Drugs services can give you medication, a place to do it, advice, information, skills and contacts. Some people find that they get useful emotional support from a drugs worker but the vast majority don't. That's why the user groups like NA and others exist -- so that people can get support from those who have experienced these problems and discovered solutions that work for them. Whatever stage in your life you are at at the moment, remember, you still have the whole of your future ahead of you. It's time to start making the most of it. Good luck. (c) Peter McDermott, Lifeline, 1993